Circulator/isolator for full-duplex - isolation vs bandwidth?

Started by CSharp_Dev_Tony · 2026-11-09 04:59 UTC · 30 views · 4 replies
C Member
Full-duplex needs serious isolation across bandwidth, and circulators always trade one for the other. What isolation-bandwidth numbers have you achieved?
L Admin
全双工里 circulator/isolator 的隔离–带宽折中,实务上很少「一只器件搞定」。编辑部侧常见做法:

1) 预算拆开:天线端隔离、环行器隔离、数字域 SIC、模拟抵消各算一截。只追环行器 40+ dB 宽带往往代价是插损和体积。
2) 带宽:窄带(几十 MHz)铁氧体环行器更容易到 20–25 dB;要跨百 MHz 以上,常见是多级级联或换到平衡结构 + 有源抵消。
3) 功率与温度:隔离度随功率/温度漂,验收要扫工作温区与峰值功率,不要只报小信号 S 参数。

欢迎贴目标带宽、TX 功率、实测隔离/插损,以及是纯无源还是混合抵消。有「只靠环行器失败 → 加抵消成功」的对比更好。

— rfforum 编辑部 / Editorial Team
R Member
The isolation-bandwidth trade-off is real, and in practice I have never seen a single passive circulator carry a full-duplex link on its own. A ferrite circulator is usually good for 20-25 dB of isolation over a few tens of MHz, with insertion loss around 0.3-0.5 dB, and the isolation falls off quickly at the band edges because the ferrite resonance and the matching network both move with frequency. If you need 40 dB or more across a wide band, plan the budget in layers rather than asking the circulator for all of it.

The layering that worked for us was: antenna isolation first, then the circulator, then analogue cancellation, then digital self-interference cancellation. Each stage only needs to be good at what it is good at. The circulator handles the bulk of the direct leakage, a simple analogue canceller with a tapped TX sample removes the dominant leakage path including the antenna reflection, and the digital stage cleans up the residual and the nonlinear products. Trying to squeeze another 10 dB out of the circulator usually cost more in insertion loss and size than adding a modest analogue canceller.

Two things to measure before choosing a part: first, isolation versus TX power and temperature, not just small-signal S-parameters, because ferrite isolation drifts with both. Second, isolation with your actual antenna attached, not a 50 ohm load, because the antenna return loss feeds directly back into the leakage path. What bandwidth and TX power are you targeting, and how much isolation can your digital cancellation already provide?
R Member
Marking this - our project starts something similar next month, learning from everyone's experience.
P Member
Quick question: is the main advantage here performance or cost compared to the classic approach?
广告 AdRenesas 瑞萨微控制器芯片产品照片Renesas Electronics微控制器、模拟与射频/时钟方案 · MCUs, analog, RF and timing访问官网 →免费展示 · 资料来自公开信息 · 如需撤下请联系 ads@rfforum.com
广告 Ad广告位招商 / Advertise hereads@rfforum.com · 刊例 Rate cardT2 · 728×90
Log in or register to reply.