R
Member
Not every lab has a load-pull tuner. I spent years doing PA matching with a VNA, a handful of fixed loads, and a lot of patience. Here is the workflow that actually works.
First, the theory in one paragraph. A PA's optimum load is rarely 50 ohms. The device wants to see the load that maximizes output power or efficiency, and that impedance is usually low and reactive. A tuner finds it by sweeping. Without one, you approximate it with discrete loads and interpolation.
Step 1: start from the datasheet load line. For a Class AB device, the optimum resistive load is roughly (Vdd - Vknee) / Imax. Calculate it, then transform it to the package reference plane with the output matching network you already have. This gives you a starting point, not an answer, but it keeps you from wandering.
Step 2: build a small load bank. I use a set of short lengths of microstrip with different widths, each soldered to an SMA connector, plus a few fixed attenuator pads as lossy loads. Measure each one on the VNA at the operating frequency and record the impedance on a Smith chart. Ten to twelve loads spread around the expected optimum is enough.
Step 3: measure output power and efficiency at each load. Keep input power fixed, keep the bias fixed, and record Pout, PAE, and gain for every load. Plot Pout contours on the Smith chart by hand or in a spreadsheet. The contours close around the optimum. Two or three iterations of refining the load bank near the peak usually gets within 0.3 dB of what a tuner would find.
Step 4: watch the traps. The first is stability: a load that gives great power can also push the device toward oscillation, so check the spectrum at every load, not just at the end. The second is harmonic termination: a load that looks right at the fundamental can present a terrible harmonic impedance, and your efficiency number will lie to you. Measure the second harmonic power at the output while you sweep.
Step 5: verify with the real matching network. Once you pick the target impedance, design the matching network, build it, and re-measure. The network's own loss shifts the optimum slightly, so expect one round of tweaking. If the measured Pout is more than 0.5 dB below the load-bank peak, something in the network is lossier than modeled, usually a via or a capacitor with higher ESR than the datasheet claims.
One practical note: keep the load bank calibrated. A load that drifted 0.2 dB in return loss will move your contour center enough to cost you real efficiency. I re-measure the bank every few months.
Have you done load-pull without a tuner? What did you use as your load set, and how close did you get to the tuner result?
First, the theory in one paragraph. A PA's optimum load is rarely 50 ohms. The device wants to see the load that maximizes output power or efficiency, and that impedance is usually low and reactive. A tuner finds it by sweeping. Without one, you approximate it with discrete loads and interpolation.
Step 1: start from the datasheet load line. For a Class AB device, the optimum resistive load is roughly (Vdd - Vknee) / Imax. Calculate it, then transform it to the package reference plane with the output matching network you already have. This gives you a starting point, not an answer, but it keeps you from wandering.
Step 2: build a small load bank. I use a set of short lengths of microstrip with different widths, each soldered to an SMA connector, plus a few fixed attenuator pads as lossy loads. Measure each one on the VNA at the operating frequency and record the impedance on a Smith chart. Ten to twelve loads spread around the expected optimum is enough.
Step 3: measure output power and efficiency at each load. Keep input power fixed, keep the bias fixed, and record Pout, PAE, and gain for every load. Plot Pout contours on the Smith chart by hand or in a spreadsheet. The contours close around the optimum. Two or three iterations of refining the load bank near the peak usually gets within 0.3 dB of what a tuner would find.
Step 4: watch the traps. The first is stability: a load that gives great power can also push the device toward oscillation, so check the spectrum at every load, not just at the end. The second is harmonic termination: a load that looks right at the fundamental can present a terrible harmonic impedance, and your efficiency number will lie to you. Measure the second harmonic power at the output while you sweep.
Step 5: verify with the real matching network. Once you pick the target impedance, design the matching network, build it, and re-measure. The network's own loss shifts the optimum slightly, so expect one round of tweaking. If the measured Pout is more than 0.5 dB below the load-bank peak, something in the network is lossier than modeled, usually a via or a capacitor with higher ESR than the datasheet claims.
One practical note: keep the load bank calibrated. A load that drifted 0.2 dB in return loss will move your contour center enough to cost you real efficiency. I re-measure the bank every few months.
Have you done load-pull without a tuner? What did you use as your load set, and how close did you get to the tuner result?
