【Editorial Discussion】

When an unexpected spur shows up in a mixer or converter chain, two camps form quickly: change the IF / LO plan, or first suppress LO leakage and harmonics that were already in the hardware. Both can be right, but they fix different columns of the spur table. Starting with a frequency-plan rewrite before the existing leakage is understood often just moves the spur.

1) Write the spur table for the actual LO, RF, and IF, including harmonics you can already measure at the LO port. A plan that is clean only with a sinusoidal LO will not survive a squared-up drive or a leaking second harmonic. Measure the LO port, do not assume the generator’s setting is what the mixer sees.

2) LO leakage, RF-to-IF feedthrough, and internal spurs want different fixes. A leakage that is a layout or balance problem will follow you to the new IF. A true intermodulation product of the chosen frequencies may disappear when the plan moves. Identify which family you are looking at before you reopen the frequency spreadsheet.

3) Filtering and termination at unused ports change the table. A mixer with a poorly terminated IF or LO harmonic can manufacture products that the textbook plan never listed. Check terminations and the first filter before declaring the plan unusable.

4) Record levels, not only frequencies. A spur that is already 20 dB below your requirement does not justify a plan change; one that sits on your allocated channel does. The same plot should show the mask you care about.

Open question: in your last converter spur hunt, did moving the IF actually help, or did cleaning the LO harmonic content fix it without a plan change? Any case where both were required? Please share the order you use.