Hairpin / edge-coupled filter that moved 80 MHz because etch undercut was never in the stack-up

Started by LunaWei · 2026-11-17 01:48 UTC · 14 views · 1 replies
L Admin
[Technical article / FAQ, rfforum Editorial Team]

A microstrip hairpin or edge-coupled filter that comes back 50-100 MHz low (or high) is often not a ceramic εr surprise. Etch undercut, plating build-up, and a stack-up card that listed "finished line width" as the simulated width move the coupled sections first. The schematic was never the patient.

1. What the etch owns
- Coupled-line filters are more sensitive to gap and edge profile than to a small length error. Undercut narrows the strip and widens the gap; both lower coupling and shift the passband.
- A fab drawing that quotes "0.20 mm line / 0.15 mm gap, as drawn" is not the same as the etched and plated geometry. If the EM used the drawing, the board will not.
- Soldermask over tight gaps changes effective εr and coupling. A first article without mask can "pass" and then move after coating.

2. Freeze list before you retune the layout in the CAD
- Finished (etched + plated) width and gap from a microsection or a coupon, not only the Gerber number
- Stack-up: foil type, plating, and whether the sim used as-drawn or as-etched edges
- Mask on/off A/B on the same coupon if the production part is masked
- A one-line coupon of the coupled section, or at least a TDR / unpopulated filter S21, before a full ECO

3. Habit
Never freeze "εr was wrong" from a single shifted filter with no etch measurement. Archive finished geometry and mask state next to every first-article passband claim. If the coupon with measured etch lands on the measured S21, stop blaming the laminate lot.

4. Practical gate
- Measure finished line/gap on the failing panel
- Re-sim with that geometry (and mask if present)
- Only then decide between a compensation etch factor, a gap tweak, or a real material change

Discussion: on your last "filter landed off frequency" ticket, did the fix land in etch factor, soldermask, or a real εr - and do you require a finished-geometry coupon before a layout respin?

— rfforum 编辑部 / Editorial Team
L Admin
Addendum — freeze finished geometry before a CAD ECO. A microsection or a coupled-section coupon from the failing panel (etched + plated width and gap, mask on or off) belongs on the same sheet as the S21 overlay. Re-sim with that geometry; if the coupon lands on the measured passband, stop the laminate-lot ticket.

Plating mushrooming can close a gap after an etch-factor compensation that only modelled undercut. Archive foil type, plating, and whether the original EM used as-drawn or as-etched edges. A first article without soldermask that later moves after coating is a mask story, not a new er.

Open: on your last off-frequency hairpin or edge-coupled filter, did the fix land in etch factor, soldermask, or a real material change — and do you require a finished-geometry coupon before a layout respin?

— rfforum 编辑部 / Editorial Team
广告 AdRenesas 瑞萨微控制器芯片产品照片Renesas Electronics微控制器、模拟与射频/时钟方案 · MCUs, analog, RF and timing访问官网 →免费展示 · 资料来自公开信息 · 如需撤下请联系 ads@rfforum.com
广告 Ad广告位招商 / Advertise hereads@rfforum.com · 刊例 Rate cardT2 · 728×90
Log in or register to reply.