R
Member
De-embedding is not one operation, and treating it as one is where most 40 GHz measurements go wrong. A calibration removes the instrument's errors up to a reference plane; de-embedding removes what sits between that plane and the device. These are different corrections and they fail in different ways.
What a calibration actually removes: directivity, tracking, and port match of the VNA, plus the connectors and cables up to the plane where the standards were applied. It does not remove the fixture's own transition, the launch on the board, or the connector that was never characterised.
What de-embedding must supply: a model or measured S-parameters of the fixture between the reference plane and the DUT. Two ways to get it - electromagnetic simulation of the launch, or a set of characterised structures (thru, line, reflect) fabricated on the same stackup.
Where it goes wrong, in order of frequency:
1) Wrong reference plane. If the standards were applied at the cable end but the fixture adds 8 mm of line, you have de-embedded nothing and simply moved the error. Sanity check: measure a known 3 dB attenuator in the fixture; if you read 2.2 dB, the plane is wrong or the fixture loss is unaccounted.
2) Model built on the wrong stackup. Simulated launch with nominal Dk/Df, while the actual board came from a different prepreg batch, gives a correction that is confidently wrong. At 40 GHz a few percent of Dk moves the phase enough to change the extracted device parameters.
3) Connector repeatability ignored. Re-mate the same connector five times and watch S11. If it moves by more than a couple of tenths of a dB, the connector - not the DUT - is setting your measurement floor.
4) De-embedding a lossy fixture with a lossless model. Phase-only correction looks fine on insertion loss and hides the fact that you have removed attenuation that was never there.
Practical order I use: characterise the fixture alone first, verify it against a known load and a known attenuator, then de-embed, then measure the DUT at two temperatures. If the de-embedded result changes shape with temperature, the correction is probably absorbing something it should not.
Question: are you de-embedding with simulated launch models or with fabricated TRL structures on the same panel? The second is more work but it fails honestly.
What a calibration actually removes: directivity, tracking, and port match of the VNA, plus the connectors and cables up to the plane where the standards were applied. It does not remove the fixture's own transition, the launch on the board, or the connector that was never characterised.
What de-embedding must supply: a model or measured S-parameters of the fixture between the reference plane and the DUT. Two ways to get it - electromagnetic simulation of the launch, or a set of characterised structures (thru, line, reflect) fabricated on the same stackup.
Where it goes wrong, in order of frequency:
1) Wrong reference plane. If the standards were applied at the cable end but the fixture adds 8 mm of line, you have de-embedded nothing and simply moved the error. Sanity check: measure a known 3 dB attenuator in the fixture; if you read 2.2 dB, the plane is wrong or the fixture loss is unaccounted.
2) Model built on the wrong stackup. Simulated launch with nominal Dk/Df, while the actual board came from a different prepreg batch, gives a correction that is confidently wrong. At 40 GHz a few percent of Dk moves the phase enough to change the extracted device parameters.
3) Connector repeatability ignored. Re-mate the same connector five times and watch S11. If it moves by more than a couple of tenths of a dB, the connector - not the DUT - is setting your measurement floor.
4) De-embedding a lossy fixture with a lossless model. Phase-only correction looks fine on insertion loss and hides the fact that you have removed attenuation that was never there.
Practical order I use: characterise the fixture alone first, verify it against a known load and a known attenuator, then de-embed, then measure the DUT at two temperatures. If the de-embedded result changes shape with temperature, the correction is probably absorbing something it should not.
Question: are you de-embedding with simulated launch models or with fabricated TRL structures on the same panel? The second is more work but it fails honestly.
